If you’re researching Metal America before placing an order, you’re in the right place. This page collects real feedback from contractors, builders, and property owners across Idaho and Washington who have purchased and installed Metal America roofing and siding panels.

The short answer to “is Metal America good?” is yes, consistently. Metal America holds a strong reputation in the Inland Northwest for product quality, knowledgeable staff, competitive pricing, and reliable turnaround. Below, you’ll find a full picture of Metal America’s reputation: what customers praise, what to know before you buy, and where to leave or read reviews across multiple platforms.

Overall: What the Reviews Say

Across Google, direct testimonials, and contractor referrals, Metal America reviews consistently highlight five themes:

• Product Quality: Panels arrive clean, straight, and true to spec. Contractors note that Metal America panels install efficiently and perform as expected in the field.
• Knowledgeable Staff: Customers frequently mention that Metal America’s team truly knows metal. Staff can discuss panel geometry, gauge selection, coating options, and installation considerations with intelligence and experience.
• Competitive Pricing: Because Metal America manufactures in-house at its Post Falls, Idaho facility, prices routinely beat regional distributors. Multiple Metal America roofing reviews mention this as a deciding factor.
• Fast Turnaround: Same-day pickup is available at both locations on standard stock items. Custom orders turn around faster than most customers expect.
• Walk-In Convenience: The ability to walk in, see samples in person, and leave with materials the same day is a recurring positive in Metal America siding reviews and roofing feedback alike.

 

Metal America Reviews from Contractors

The majority of Metal America’s customer base is made up of professional builders and contractors. Metal america roofing reviews from this group focus on consistency, availability, and the value of working with a local manufacturer rather than a national distributor.

 

★★★★★ “In our business, reliability matters just as much as craftsmanship. Metal America consistently delivers both. Their combination of product quality, design variety, dependable supply, and outstanding customer support has made them an integral part of our operations and a trusted partner in our continued growth.” Dan Neace Triple 5 Construction

 

★★★★★ “As the owner of MaxForce I worked closely with the team at Metal America to design and install the first all metal printed fence. The entire team was professional, easy to work with, and helped every step of the way. If you are interested in a fence or metal for your project, I would highly recommend Tim or any member of the team at Metal America.” Rob Egusquiza MaxForce

 

★★★★★ “As a concrete contractor, I recently had the opportunity to work with Metal America on a commercial building project. The experience was excellent from start to finish. The quality of the metal materials met our expectations, and the entire process was smooth and efficient. I highly recommend Metal America to anyone looking for a reliable and professional supplier for commercial projects.” Iggy Valdovinos IGGY’S Concrete

 

★★★★★ “I appreciate the people at Metal America because they know what they’re talking about when you call to order something. They have everything we need for metal building work and more.” Mark Avena Charis Construction Inc.

 

Metal America Reviews from Homeowners and Owner-Builders

We sell directly to homeowners, owner-builders, and DIY barndominium builders as well. Metal America customer reviews from this group frequently highlight the experience of walking in without a contractor’s license and receiving the same expert attention as a professional builder.

 

★★★★★ “I was building my own shop and had no idea where to start with metal roofing. The team at Metal America Post Falls walked me through every option, helped me pick the right panel and color, and had everything ready same day. The panels went on perfectly. I’ll be back for the siding.” Owner-Builder, Coeur d’Alene, ID

 

★★★★★ “Went in to the Spokane Valley location to get samples. Ended up staying 45 minutes talking through our barndominium project. They knew every finish, could explain the difference between panels, and didn’t try to upsell us on anything we didn’t need. Genuinely helpful. Ordered everything through them.” Homeowner, Spokane Valley, WA

 

Metal America Reviews: Spokane

The Metal America Spokane Valley location at 13520 E Nora Ave serves Spokane and the surrounding Eastern Washington area. Spokane customers leave consistently note the walk-in experience, same-day availability, and the quality of in-person product guidance.

 

★★★★★ “Best metal panel supplier in Eastern Washington. The wood-look finishes are unreal — my customers can’t believe it’s steel. Metal America is the only place I go for siding in the Spokane market now.” Home Builder, South Hill, Spokane, WA

 

★★★★★ “We did a large commercial re-roof on the North Side using Metal America’s standing seam panels. The Spokane Valley team was responsive, the panels arrived on schedule, and everything installed flawlessly. We’ll be back.” Commercial Roofing Contractor, Spokane, WA

 

★★★★★ “We’ve been sourcing panels from Metal America Spokane Valley for over two years. The quality is consistent, pricing is better than any distributor we’ve used, and the team actually knows metal — they’ve helped us spec panels correctly on every single job.” General Contractor, Spokane Valley, WA

 

Metal America Reviews: Idaho

Metal America’s headquarters and manufacturing facility is in Post Falls, Idaho. Idaho customers spanning Coeur d’Alene, Hayden, Sandpoint, and the broader Panhandle, frequently cite proximity to the source as a key advantage.

 

★★★★★ “Metal America has been our go-to for every roofing job in the Panhandle for the past three years. The Post Falls team knows their product inside and out. Lead times are short, pricing is fair, and the quality doesn’t vary order to order. That consistency is everything in this business.” Roofing Contractor, Coeur d’Alene, ID

 

★★★★★ “I drove out to the Post Falls location after looking at panels online and it was absolutely worth it. Being able to hold the panels, see the wood finishes in person, and talk to someone who actually installs this stuff made all the difference. Placed my order on the spot.” Owner-Builder, Hayden, ID

 

Metal America Roofing Reviews

From QuickLoc™ standing seam on residential builds to PBR and Tuff Rib on agricultural structures. Common themes across roofing feedback include:

• Panel quality and dimensional consistency: cuts cleanly, installs true, no oil-canning on standing seam profiles
• Coating durability: the WeatherXL™ SMP finish holds color and resists chalking in the Inland Northwest’s UV-heavy summers and cold winters
• Standing seam performance: QuickLoc™ in particular receives strong marks from contractors for its interlocking system and ease of installation
• Snow performance: contractors in North Idaho and Eastern Washington note that standing seam profiles handle snow load and ice dam conditions well

 

★★★★★ “We’ve put QuickLoc on probably 30 roofs at this point. It installs clean, the colors stay true, and we’ve had zero callbacks. Metal America’s panels are as consistent as any I’ve used, and the pricing makes it easy to stay loyal.” Residential Roofing Contractor, Post Falls, ID

 

Metal America Siding Reviews

Metal America siding reviews are increasingly driven by the wood-look finish collection. Contractors and homeowners alike reach for Metal America when they want the aesthetics of wood siding without the maintenance and the feedback reflects that the product delivers.

• Board & Batten in Barnwood and Smooth Cedar finishes receives consistent praise for the realism of the 8K print
• Shiplap and Double Lap profiles are popular on residential projects, farmhouses, and event venue builds
• Installers note that the panels cut cleanly, trim accessories align well, and the finished product looks custom

 

★★★★★ “The Smooth Cedar Board & Batten we used on a recent barndominium project stopped people in their tracks. Every single person asked if it was real wood. It’s not. It’s steel so it will still look like that in 40 years. That’s the pitch. It sells itself.” Builder, Spokane Valley, WA

 

Is Metal America Good? Our Honest Assessment

Based on customer feedback, contractor repeat business, and our own product standards: yes, Metal America is a good company to work with, particularly if you’re in the Pacific Northwest and value local manufacturing, product knowledge, and quick availability.

Here’s what the reviews consistently support:

• Quality is consistent. Unlike some distributors who source from variable third-party manufacturers, Metal America rolls its own panels. That means dimensional consistency from order to order.
• Staff knowledge is genuine. Shawn and Justin Sternberg have 25 years of installation experience between them. That background filters through the entire team. Customers are not talking to order-takers, they’re talking to people who understand metal.
• Pricing is competitive. In-house manufacturing eliminates distributor markups. Multiple customers have compared Metal America’s pricing against regional distributors and found it lower for comparable product.
• Turnaround is fast. Standard stock items are available same-day at both locations. Custom lengths typically ship within a few business days.
• Walk-in locations add real value. The ability to see samples, ask questions, and leave with materials in hand is something no online-only supplier can replicate. Customers who have used both models consistently prefer the in-person Metal America experience.

The one thing to know: Metal America is a manufacturer and supplier, not an installation contractor. If you’re looking for someone to install your roof or siding, Metal America can often refer you to qualified local installers, but the core business is the panels themselves.

 

Where to Read or Leave a Metal America Review

If you’ve worked with Metal America and want to share your experience, or if you’re researching before placing an order, here’s where to find Metal America customer reviews:

Google Business Profile

The most active source of Metal America customer reviews. Search “Metal America Post Falls” or “Metal America Spokane Valley” on Google Maps to see current ratings and read or leave a review.

Direct Testimonials

Some of the reviews posted in this article are verified testimonials. These are sourced directly from customers who have completed projects using Metal America panels.

Contractor Referrals

The best evidence of Metal America’s reputation is repeat contractor business. If you’re working with a local builder or roofer in the Inland Northwest, ask them where they source their panels. A significant portion of active contractors in the region have worked with Metal America.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Metal America Reviews

 

Ready to Work with Metal America?

Visit either of our walk-in locations or contact us to request a quote. Our team is available Monday through Friday at both our Post Falls, Idaho and Spokane Valley, Washington locations.

• Phone: 855-638-2587
• Email: sales@metalamerica.com
• Post Falls, ID: 7728 Corn Maze Way | Mon–Thu: 7 AM–4 PM, Fri: 7 AM–2 PM
• Spokane Valley, WA: 13520 E Nora Ave | Mon–Fri: 8 AM–4 PM

 

Metal America® is a registered trademark. All panels manufactured at our Post Falls, ID facility. © 2026 Metal America. All rights reserved.